For anyone who wants a sig to link here from other forums, but feels too lazy to write their own (hi Ryan* ), here's the one I've come up with:
Feel free to suggest improvements, or complete rewrites. (to kill the joke by explaining it, a popular critique of utilitarianism - that I won't bother to dissect here - is a thought experiment involving our fiery-follicled brethren. The argument, which I think originated from Murray Rothbard's Libertarian Manifesto, is that we can imagine a society where everyone hates redheads so much that the thought of their existence causes them great mental anguish, where the best way to maximise happiness would be to kill all the redheads. This would infringe their natural libertarian rights, therefore utilitarianism fails.
Tremendously persuasive stuff.)
* Ryan has done huge amounts of work on this forum, and I mock him from sadism, not reason.
Felicifia - a place for consequentialists and utilitarians to hang out, fix the world, and not murder redheads.
Feel free to suggest improvements, or complete rewrites. (to kill the joke by explaining it, a popular critique of utilitarianism - that I won't bother to dissect here - is a thought experiment involving our fiery-follicled brethren. The argument, which I think originated from Murray Rothbard's Libertarian Manifesto, is that we can imagine a society where everyone hates redheads so much that the thought of their existence causes them great mental anguish, where the best way to maximise happiness would be to kill all the redheads. This would infringe their natural libertarian rights, therefore utilitarianism fails.
Tremendously persuasive stuff.)
* Ryan has done huge amounts of work on this forum, and I mock him from sadism, not reason.