Suppose a person has a constant, uncontrollable desire to inflict pain on emself. This is distinct from masochism, because a masochist can in some sense be said to enjoy the pain. But this person feels only unpleasant experiences when ey inflicts pain on emself. Ey feels terribly unhappy in ever possible sense, but still feels a strong desire to experience more pain.
Should preference utilitarians accept that it is morally right to inflict pain on this person?
Should preference utilitarians accept that it is morally right to inflict pain on this person?